Thursday, September 11, 2008

SRF and the Mortgage Mess

In the last post I noted that Shared Risk Financing eliminates the need for re-insurance. Therefore, this reduces the need for re-insurance schemes like Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae.

The Mortgage Mess happened because housing prices did not increase at the rate anticipated by borrowers. A large number of people owe more than their home is worth and are walking away from mortgages. There is a liquidity crises because banks have no way to know what their mortgage portfolio is worth.

Switching troubled loans from the mortgage to a shared risk contract would give the parties involved a clear idea of what they owned, and would restore liquidity.

A borrower would move from the situation where they owe a fixed amount on a house, for which they don't know the value. The lender would move from a situation where they have a fixed loan but don't know if the borrow will ever pay them back to actually owning a share of property which can be valued and traded.

The initial act of valuing and trading the SRF's would created a mini financial boon as the market re-aligns. The Feds would probably have to pour some cash into the pot to help home owners seriously underwater. The SRFs put the primary parties into a situation where they have better knowledge of their assets.

Shared Risk and Reinsurance

I did some more thinking on the shared ownership concept I spat out a few days ago.

First, I decided to rename the idea Shared-Risk-Financing Shared-Equity-Financing.

Edited 9/6/2010: I changed the name to Shared Equity Financing to emphasize the investment aspects of the scheme.

Shared equity financing dramatically eliminates the need for massive re-insurance programs like Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.

The mortgage industry was created by bankers who wanted a guaranteed income from the paper money created by the Feds. In this scheme, bankers borrow money at a fixed rate from the government then loans it to a home owner at a fixed rate. The bank's income is the difference between the two rates.

This scheme requires a re-insurance mechanism because the fixed rate scheme is untenable in times of economic duress. When prices dip, people are uable (or are unwilling) to pay back the high interest loans. Banks suddenly lose liquidity and are unable to make new loans, and the market freezes.

This mortgage structure is inherently unstable.

The inherent instability of mortgages created the need for big federal re-insurance programs. The idea behind these programs is that real-estate cycles tend to be local. The hope of re-insurance is that, if there is a liquidity crisis in one real estate market, the re-insurance scheme could rush money from other markets into the squeezed market and stave off local economic failure.

The great fault of the re-insurance programs is that such programs eventually turn the whole country into a single market with a deeper systemic fault. The big reinsurance schemes create the conditions where our whole nation (if not the whole world economy) will periodically suffer sudden and severe economic crisis.

Shared Equity Financing does not use an artificial fixed interest rate. The home owner and creditor share the ups and downs of housing prices. With such a scheme you never lose total liquidity as you do with mortgage financing.

Tuesday, September 09, 2008

500 Blogs

I just noticed that my blog roll recently crossed the 500 mark. The blogs are listed by community.

Yes, I have read a good number of posts on all the blogs. Even the ones that make me angry.

Yes, the roll includes links back to me.

I mean someone has to link to me.

If you are wondering. A big blog roll that includes links to people of diverse opinions does not result in reciprocal links. I was just checking Google return links. The links are pretty much all just me linking to myself.

I guess the thing that compels me to make large lists of links to people regardless of persuasion is that I realized long ago that most people are excluded from the inner core of society, and that the perspective from the outside is usually more interesting than the view from the inner circle.

When I started this blog, I thought about making a partisan attack dog type blog ... you know, the kind of blog where people form little partisan attack groups with a small number of links to similar attack dogs. Partisan strategies gets the higher technorati scores. But I would rather go the unrestricted mindfart route and explore ideas, even when the ideas aren't politically correct.

The page counter on my blog roll says the pages have been viewed some 26,000 times. It is likely that most of the hits are from robots. My internal logs show that about 10% of the traffic on the Community Color sites is from bots.

I like to think that the list is giving people in the community some exposure that they would not have without the effort.

BTW, I will pretty much list any blog from the Mountain West (Colorado, Utah, etc). The gaol of the blog roll is to show the diversity of opinion in select communities. If you are from the areas served and aren't included yet, just drop a comment to this page, or use the add link form.

Because I have limited time, I reject sites that are not from the communities referenced on the blog list. If I had infinite resources, I would make a list of all communities. As it stands, I must portion my effort.

A Cluttered Cabinet

John McCain says he will include Democrats in his cabinet.

Hey, wait a second, that is essentially what George Bush did! Of course, in Bush's case, the lefties in his administration called themselves "neocon" and swore personal fealty to Bush in their grasp for power and thier cut of that ever so sweet government manna that comes from the like of Fannie Mae.

McCain's promise of overt bipartisanship is a welcome change.

Both Bush and Clinton tried the ruse of covert bipartisanship. The strategy of the fiscally conservative Democrat and compassionate conservative was an attempt to steal issues from their opponents with the notion that through such schizophrenic action, they could buy unending power. Elinor Burkett's Baby Boon shows how Clinton sold out the feminist constituency for a power grab at the family friendly center.

Bush shouted down fiscal conservatives in the Republican party, and committed the a sin in the eyes of the traditional Republican of invading Iraq without really thinking through the end game. Both the Powell Doctrine and Constitution of the United States demand greater scrutiny before engaging in things such as war.

The idea of invading a country in order to effect some sort of nebulous change is the antithesis of traditional Republican thought.

Bush and Clinton were both centrist candidates. The candidates wanted their names associated with the center. The problem with this type of character is that, when they make compromises, the candidates are so eager to get their name associated with the centrist legislation that they fail to acknowledge compromises as compromises. They fail to give credit to their opponents. Sucn an approach to politics makes members of the opposition party feel cut out and belittled and leads to angry self destructive politics.

A better approach to centrism and compromise is to keep one's message clear and to openly acknowledge compromises.

Back to McCain. McCain's decision to draw cabinet members might be a good sign. A cabinet that overtly acknowledges that it is drawing ideas from different ideological traditions might help our leaders maintain the integrity of their message.

IMHO, bipartisan efforts do better when the players openly acknowledge who they are, and overtly engage in discourse. In such a situation, the compromises are clear and different parties feel engaged. Efforts fail when politics is about backstabbing and undermining others in the grub for power and those ever so lucrative connections to Fannie and Freddie.

I think McCain is one of the few politicians who could pull off a mixed cabinet. I don't think Obama has experience at this point in his career to pull off a bipartisan cabinet. I don't think Bush had the clarity of vision to pull off a bipartisan cabinet either.

Monday, September 08, 2008

Shared Ownership

In my last post I ranted about the mortgage mess. Ranting is easy. Coming up with a solution to the mess is harder. People want solutions. Here goes a post on a possible long term solution.

My solution is a radical thing that starts by re-assessing mortgages altogether.

A mortgage is a thing where you borrow money to buy a home and pay interest on the loan. The interest rate is set by the global money market. This rate is manipulated by centralized banks such as the Federal Reserve, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.

The loans are made by banks seeking a guaranteed income from their investment. From a macro view, this system is untenable. You have groups trying to get an assured income on trillions of dollars in investments.

Libertarians often rant against this structure calling it "rent-seeking."

The paradigm has borrowers bearing the entire risk of homeownership. This type of system seems to work when prices are rising. Unfortunately, there is no such thing as a perfect market where prices run up forever. When the market slows down or dips, the last people in the market get hurt big time.

Imagine a person borrowed $100k in 2006 to buy a $100k house. They worked hard and paid $20k of their loan. In the mean time, the house dropped in value to $80k. Their bank statement would show they had $20k equity on a loan, while in reality they have zero real equity in their home. If they are forced to sell, the homeowner can kiss their money goodbye.

A more equitable way to go about housing is to develop a system of shared ownership. In a system of shared ownership, multiple groups would have a stake in a house. Imagine the same house where the home buyers had an arrangement of shared ownership. Imagine that, at the purchase of the house, the homeowners had a shared ownership arrangement where the value of the house was split into 100 shares. During the years, they bought back 20 of the shares for $20. When the home buyers were force to sell in a down market, they would have a real 20% equity in the home and would get $16k when the house sells at $80k.

I should note that homeowners and the bank would share in both the risks and rewards of homes. The shared ownership notes would trade on a market and would rise and fall with investor's expectations of the market.

It would take a long dissertation to explain how contracts and the mathematics around shared ownership would work. People are very good at writing contracts.

The public debate should focus on the distinction between sharing ownership and mortgaging ownership.

I contend that sharing ownership builds community, while the mortgage process encourages a gambler's approach to housing and ultimately forces people into subservience to the banking community.
NOTE (9/11/2008): I decided that Shared Risk Financing is a better name for what I described in this post, than shared ownership.

Saturday, September 06, 2008

Doing Unto Healthcare

I admit, a year ago, the mortgage mess had me baffled. I couldn't figure out how mortgage portfolios got so toxic so quickly.

The excuse I heard from the left made absolutely no sense. They said that there were horrible people called predatory lenders who loaned money to people who couldn't pay the money back. These horrible people caused the mess.

I have no doubt that there are horrible people in this world. However, companies that make loans that never get paid back tend to go under. The free market would weed out such clowns.

A year into the crisis, when it is time to put taxpayers' dollars where the pundits' mouths are, we get to see the real cause of the mortgage mess.

The real cause of the mortgage mess are two comic book characters from the New Deal called Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.

These two government spawned entities that handle half of the mortgage re-insurance. The two behemoths masquerade as private companies so that their actions would not be reflected in the government books. The companies would buy and repackage mortgage portfolios, with the tacit understanding that they would get a government bailout if ever things went south.)

So, just like the Savings and Loan Crisis of the 1980s, we find our financial markets mucked up by incompetent political drones. The S&L Crisis as enabled by another creation of FDR called the FSLIC that re-insured Savings and Loans.

So, the mortgage mess of 2008 is the second major financial crisis caused by Saint Roosevelt

The reason I filed this post under health care is that this re-insurance model is exactly the type of program that intellectual giants like Mitt Romney and Hillary Clinton want to define the health care industry.

BTW, I suspect that the neocons are partially to blame. A neocon is a Democrat who became a Republicans when it was politically expedient. The mantra of the neocons was to encourage ownership. Their ideology would be to use the power of the Fannie Mae and Feddie Mac to encourage risky loans, failing to realize that they were undermining their cause.

Statists can make the claim that it was the horrible neocons that enabled the horrible predatory lenders that caused their precious comic book companies Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac to behave comically.

Hidden behind statist excusism is the absurd notion that the comical government schemes to control markets for social justice are premised on having a perfect person with clairvoyant powers to oversee the agencies.

The reality is that these big government agencies work by thrashing from crisis to crisis. You have one big crisis and thrash to the next big crisis.

As fortunes dwindle in this mortgage mess, I hope people realize the inherent absurdity of the big government programs that are supposed to let us live below financial sea level without drowning in our own stupidity.

Sadly, in the same year that we suffer the mortgage mess, we are likely to vote in a president who wants to do unto health care what Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac did unto the housing market.

Friday, September 05, 2008

Symptoms and Causes

A major point of McCain's speech was that the cynicism in political discourse is a symptom of the corruption in Congress and the halls of power.

I think things are different, and far worse than McCain imagines. The cynicism is not the result of our politics. I believe that the cynicism, corruption, divisive politics, et al., are a result of the way our school system teaches us to be.

Our public schools teach a form of material dialectics as interpreted by John Dewey, Chomsky and other leftist intellectuals who've managed to infiltrate and control the leading positions in the American intellectual community.

The left yanked the study of classic logic out of the public schools. Students no longer learn the distinction between logic and rhetoric. We have developed a new rational style where politicians simply judge their speaking on its affectiveness. As we were not trained to appreciate truth, few politicos consider the question of what is right or wrong as they pen their speeches. The simply consider what is effective in advancing their partisan cause.

With politicians driven by the believe that all is fair in the path to power, they will give mean mean spirited speeches filled sith taunts and barbs. The hope is that people will vote based on feeling and not reason.

Since this is what we are taught in school. Both sides engage in this practice.

Of course, taunts and barbs were part of the classical tradition. For that matter negative discourse is part of quality discourse. In a political campaign, candidates need to differentiate themselves from their opponents. One does this by telling people the good of their position and the bad of their opponent's.

The existence of negative discourse is not the problem. The problem is one of emphasis. In the material dialectics, the foundations of the Marxist system and most leftist thought, conflict is the center of discourse. Marx did not define a what the proletarian paradise would look like. He simply gave an instruction manual for creating dissent that could be used in a rise to power.

The method is simple. You harp on people's discontents with a nebulous call for change. People fall for it, and your political machine takes control.

The really nasty thing about Marx is that he figured out how to do this manipulation at a subliminal level.

Negative statements can help improve our understanding when made at a liminal level. The really nasty divisive stuff happens when attacks are made to influence people at a subliminal level.

As pointed out in Obama's acceptance speech, the neocons did the United States a grave disservice when they created a climate where all dissent to the Iraq invasion was framed as unpatriotic. This created a climate where one could not rationally discuss whether or not the invasion would accomplish the goal of halting the radicalization of Islam.

Unfortunately, much of the anti-war effort was dominated by the radical left. Not all of it was. Just because some people painted themselves green and protested naked doesn't mean that all of the arguments against the war were equally irrational.

Political bedfellows are always strange. Some of the anti-American left was in favor of the invasion as it would mire the US in a conflict. There was a large number of groups and people on the left that gave a nod to the war, but came out against it after the fighting started.

The Founders of the US seemed to understand this process. The politicos of the world love seeing their enemies in conflict. For example, the King of France supported the American's fight against England despite the fact that doing so sealed the the demise of the royalty in France.

The founders wanted a rational debate followed by a Declaration of War before a war. The Democrats gave a tacit nod to the invasion then launched into a full court press against the war when American soldiers were in harm's way. Bush's failure to follow the prescription in the Constitution and in the Powell Doctrine did great damage to our nation.

I an so angry at the Bush and the Republican Party for the way they behaved. Yet, my anger is tempered by the realization that they played the game the way our schools teach us to play the game.

The Bush Administration could not engage in rational discourse when our left-leaning schools fail to impart an appreciation of rationality and fails to give us the tools to engage in rational discourse.

As the NEA has denied the American people the tools of reason, we are destined to be a people whipped to and fro by our sentiments.

As for negative comments. My take is to look at the negative statements and try to determine if they are part of a pattern designed to obfuscate debate and cause us make decisions at a subliminal level, or if they are part an above board effort to draw distinction between candidates.

Since we can't look inside people and see their intentions, it is an impossible task. The abuse of earmarks shows that there are rogues on both the left and right. The fact that the Republicans of the Bush Administration increased the size of government when both their rhetoric and (arguably) the will of the people was for a smaller less intrusive government, shows that many of the players on the right simply repeat whatever slogan is effective then simply grub at the government manna when they are in office.

There is not a political path out of the mire. We need schools that impart a respect for reason, and that will never happen in the context of politically charged public schools.

Wednesday, August 27, 2008

An Example of Partisan Force

Hmmm, in a prime example of partisan extremism, Bill Clinton gave an extremely partisan speech with the central theme of accusing his opponents of partisan extremism.

Projection is one of the most successful tools of the left.

I tried listening to Hillary's speech on the radio yesterday. Except annoying announcers kept breaking in to the speech.

Bill Clinton was probably the single most fortunate president in history. The US was the center of both a computer and internet boom that can happen only once in history. The boom was crowned by an artificial Y2K problem that poured bucket loads of cash into the economy.

Bill Clinton ignored the rise of the Taliban, he turned his back on the people of Rwanda, and on the secod rise of Saddam Hussein.

He is correct that single pary rule under Bush was a fiasco.

The rational style, however, is not determined by the President. The rational style is set by the schools, press and other institutions that are dominated by the left.

Real analysis of the failures of the Bush presidency is valuable. The increased volume of the partisanship was the result the of the left and not Bush.

The wank right after Clinton (Evan Bayh?) just said the most ludicrous thing I had heard in a long time. He praised Obama for supporting a timed withdrawl of American troops when Al Qaeda was winning the war and the Iraq Democracy was at its most tenuous. He then attacked Bush for starting negotiation a time table for withdrawl when it looks like the Iraq Democracy made it through its darkest hour.

For those of you who are into definitions. Withdrawing your forces when you are losing is called "surrender." Withdrawing forces after winning is called "victory."

I opposed the war. However, the way one ends a war is far more important than the way it was started. I applauded Bush's stand that we should not negotiate a timed withdrawl until there was good chance that a democracy would survive in the region.

That means we needed to find a way to draw down during a upswing.

The ending of the war is more important than its beginning. We ended Desert Storm poorly because we left Saddam in power and simply ignored Hussein's atrocities during the Clinton years.

Tuesday, August 26, 2008

Homes as Slot Machines

Honestly, I tried to listen to the DNC. I went to the TV, there was a idiot named Warner lamenting about how, because of the Great Satan George W. Bush, Americans no longer see their home as a safe investment.

First of all, seeing anything as a safe investment is stupid. Investment entails risk.

Anyway, the people who understand what an investment is and who invested in their home are sitting pretty in homes that have been and will continue to be a good investment.

The problem is with the myriad of people who see their home as a slot machine. People who see their home as a slot machine have artificially driven up prices. Just like the chattle that pulls the levers of the one-armed-bandits in Vegas, people who see their home as a slot machine tend to lose.

The Warner-bot then spouted a bunch of rhetoric about failure. "Failure" appears to be one of the Democrat's favorite words. They love accusing people of failure.

Speaking of failure, I was wondering why Warner failed to lay any blame for the housing problem on the public schools. Public schools systematically fail to teach students the simple financial knowledge they need to be able to own and keep a home.

Of course the formula of the left is simple. You denounce something as a failure. You pass tax and spend laws to solve the failure and feast on the income redistribution.

Anyway, I tried listening to the DNC. Most of it is just people trying to find ways to drive wedges in our society on their rise to power.

Conventions aren't a format where people authetically discuss and resolve issues. It is a place where central authorities issue talking points and test the effectiveness of their rhetoric.

I think I will spend the evening doing something else.

Convention Insanity

I was reading local blog posts talking about how much they wish they were in Denver at the moment. I thought the posts funny because I had decided to put off

If I had been able to pull off my plans. I would be in Denver at the moment.

Much as I want to get to the other side of the Zion Curtain, I decided to put off going to Denver for six months.

I am interested in things that build local communities. Coronation ceremonies don't build community. If the convention was about people exchanging ideas with the leadership of the party, then I think I would be there. But conventions are orchestrated media events where the anointed work to deliver a message honed for the maximum effect.

This applies to both D and R conventions. Political conventions are, by definition, a partisan event. As a partisan event, they don't build community. There is a tiny change that I could have scored an inbound link or two this blog and elevated it from the lowest possible technorati score of 1. I think I would have just been miserable.

I did watch Michelle Obama's speech on the tube. The message of change is that we should give up on the American Experiment that created a government that was well suited for the way life is, and change to a shiny new government designed for the way life ought to be.

The message was interesting in that I have been trying to figure out how to say just the opposite.

The Ancients through the Dark Ages held the ideal that happiness would come through the perfection of the centralized government ... The Empire. People fell for the line that the king (and the ruling class) lived as servants to the people. Serfs did horrible things to one another in the belief that the centralized government would take care of them when the emperor was strong.

The Renaissance and Enlightenment were defined by new intellectual efforts to apply reasoning to define the way life is, and to find the best way of governing a world the way that it is.

This effort came to fruition with the development of a slightly freer market, the protection of human rights and a limited government with democratically elected leaders. The system works. It is a shame that the people meeting in Denver want to end it.

The other thing I noticed about Michelle's speech. She spent the lion-share of the speech talking about the struggles of the working class. She spoke about people working themselves ragged to pay for health care and consumer goods. She lamented the people working two shifts to make ends meet and spoke about how it is nigh impossible for a person who is in the habit of living from pay check to pay check to pay for health care expenses.

Nowhere in the speech did she mention small business or ownership.

The paycheck to paycheck trap is untenable. There are two ways out of it. The first is for people to accept the world as it is, and for individual people to save in times of health to prepare for times of hardship. The second is to return to imperial dream where we have a massive centralized feudal system, and people hold to the delusion that the king is a servant to the people, as it ought to be.